QUESTIONS

Don't tell me what to do.

TL;DR: Embrace a question-based approach to transform how your team collaborates and innovates. Focusing on insightful questioning rather than direct directives, this method promotes a culture of ownership and proactive problem-solving. It encourages team members to think independently and contribute meaningfully, leading to more robust solutions and a motivated team environment. Whether leading a team or contributing individually, this approach will enhance your effectiveness, demonstrating your value and potential for future leadership roles.

---

Imagine your team is working on a new feature - integrating an external service into one of the most critical endpoints of your product. The team is confident they've covered all bases. However, the risks are significant: if anything goes wrong with this service, it could make the endpoint unusable, breaking your product's functionality. As a leader, you could directly point out the risk and suggest implementing a failover mechanism or a circuit breaker pattern to handle potential downtimes. This direct approach might solve the problem but risks resistance from the team, who might feel their expertise and efforts should be supported.

Here's where the power of asking questions comes in. Instead of outright suggestions, what if you ask, "What happens if this external service goes down?" This subtle shift in approach can make a significant difference. It nudges the team to identify the gap, building a sense of ownership and eagerness to find a solution. This method solves the immediate problem and builds a stronger, more collaborative team dynamic.

Mastering the skill of asking insightful questions rather than imposing solutions is invaluable. It helps guide your team to find answers, ensuring they feel invested in the project's success. This approach leads to more robust solutions and promotes a more harmonious and motivated team environment.

In this piece, we will explore why asking questions is crucial for any valuable engineer, especially those in leadership roles. We'll explore how this technique enhances team collaboration, builds ownership, and leads to more effective problem-solving. I'll also share practical tips and personal experiences to show these points. By the end, you'll understand how to apply this approach in your leadership style, ensuring your team is actively engaged and contributing to the project's success and not just following directions. Let's go!

Directives to questions

The transition from giving directives to asking questions marks a significant evolution in leadership style. This approach requires patience, active listening, and a genuine curiosity about the perspectives and ideas of your team members. For instance, instead of directly stating that a particular feature needs to be optimized for performance, you could ask, "How do you think we can enhance the performance of this feature?" This opens up a dialogue and makes team members feel valued and heard.

By asking questions, you encourage team members to reflect on their work and take greater ownership of their tasks. This method cultivates an environment where team members are more autonomous and confident in their decision-making. It's about shifting the focus from what needs to be done to how it can be done best, allowing team members to explore and propose their solutions.

This shift also promotes a more collaborative team culture. When leaders ask questions, it signals that all ideas are welcome and that the leader is open to suggestions. This inclusivity enhances team dynamics, making each member feel integral to the decision-making process. It's a powerful way to build trust and respect within the team.

Ownership and engagement

When team members uncover solutions through their responses to your questions, they cultivate a sense of ownership in their work. This ownership manifests in various ways. For instance, when a team member suggests a new caching strategy in response to a question about improving system performance, they're more likely to be invested in the implementation and success of that strategy. They're not just executing orders but bringing their ideas to life. This shift from passive participation to active engagement is crucial in fostering a sense of personal stake in the project's success.

Asking questions also naturally elevates team engagement. When a leader asks, "How could we make this feature more user-friendly?" it invites team members to put themselves in the users' shoes, leading to more thoughtful and user-centric design. This kind of engagement involves team members in a deeper, more meaningful way. Their ideas and opinions become integral to the project's direction, leading to a more passionate involvement in their work.

The practice of asking questions cultivates a work environment grounded in mutual respect and collaborative spirit. When a leader asks, "What are your thoughts on this approach?" it signals to the team that their insights are valued and essential. This inclusive approach enhances team dynamics and contributes to a positive workplace atmosphere. It's a setting where diverse ideas are welcomed and debated, leading to innovative solutions and a stronger, more unified team.

Implementation

Implementing a question-based approach into your leadership style enhances team dynamics and deepens engagement. This approach involves a delicate balance between asking questions and providing directives, ensuring that while the team is encouraged to find solutions independently, crucial issues are not overlooked. Here's an integrated strategy for effectively implementing this approach:

1. Balancing questions with directives

2. Recognize situations that require direct instructions, especially when the team misses critical issues. Begin by guiding the team towards the answer through questions, and if necessary, follow up with clear, direct guidance. This balance allows for independent thinking while ensuring key aspects are addressed.

3. Cultivating active listening

4. Start with active listening to truly understand the nuances of each situation. This not only shows respect for your team's input but also forms the basis for meaningful conversations and insightful questions.

5. Asking open-ended questions

6. Frame your questions to encourage discussion and exploration. Avoid yes/no questions; instead, prompt exploratory thinking with questions like, "What are the potential impacts of this decision?" which invite a range of perspectives.

7. Encouraging full participation

8. Some team members may be more reserved. Actively engage all team members in discussions, directing questions to quieter individuals to ensure a diversity of viewpoints.

9. Integrating questions into daily interactions

10. Regularly include questions in your interactions, whether in meetings, one-on-ones, or casual conversations. Use them to provoke thought and encourage team members to share their ideas and solutions.

11. Providing clear rationale when directing

12. When direct instructions are necessary, explain your decisions clearly. This maintains trust and clarity, even when adopting a more directive approach.

Blending a question-based approach with necessary directives creates a dynamic, engaged, and collaborative team atmosphere. This method empowers your team and fosters a culture of continuous learning and adaptability, ultimately leading to more innovative solutions and a more cohesive team environment.

Examples

As a leader, one of your key roles is facilitating effective problem-solving, creativity, and alignment within your team. The right questions are powerful tools in this mission, guiding your team toward insightful reflections and innovative solutions. Let's explore some examples of questions that significantly enhance team dynamics and project outcomes.

1. Problem-solving "What do you think are the potential drawbacks of this current approach?" This question can spark a proactive discussion on improving methods or strategies, helping to identify and address potential issues before they escalate.

2. "How might we approach this challenge if we had different constraints?" This can lead to innovative thinking and alternative solutions.

3. Creativity" Can we think of a more innovative approach to this solution?" This question challenges team members to leave their comfort zones and explore creative alternatives.

4. "What would be an unconventional but potentially effective way to tackle this problem?" Encourages thinking beyond traditional methods and fosters a culture of innovation.

5. Alignment "How does this align with our overall project goals?" This question ensures the team's efforts consistently contribute to the overarching objectives.

6. "What impact will this have on our end-users?" Keeps the team focused on creating user-centric solutions.

7. "In what ways does this align with our key performance indicators?" This helps align the team's work with measurable outcomes and organizational goals.

By adding these questions to your leadership approach, you steer your team towards a more collaborative, innovative, and results-oriented workflow. The art of asking the right questions enhances the team's problem-solving capabilities and fosters a culture of creativity and strategic alignment, which is essential for any successful project.

Quality over quantity

While fostering a culture of questions is valuable, it's crucial to recognize that not all questions contribute constructively to the discussion. The adage "there are no silly questions" doesn't always hold true in professional settings. As a team member, asking questions thoughtfully and purposefully is important. Your inquiries should move the conversation forward, not just demonstrate your ability to ask questions. Here's how to ensure your questions are impactful and meaningful:

1. Asking with intent to improve

2. Consider its purpose and potential impact before asking a question. Does it clarify confusion, contribute to solving a problem, or bring a new perspective? For instance, instead of asking a basic question that's already been addressed, you might ask, "How does this strategy align with our long-term goals?" This shows that you're thinking about the broader implications and the future.

3. Avoiding questions that slow down progress

4. Steer clear of questions that might derail or unnecessarily prolong discussions without adding value. For example, questioning a well-established basic principle can be seen as counterproductive. Focus on questions that address immediate concerns or strategic considerations.

5. Being specific and relevant

6. Ask specific questions rather than vague ones. Specificity makes your questions more actionable and relevant. For example, instead of asking, "How can we improve?", you might ask, "What specific steps can we take to enhance the performance of this feature?"

7. Timing your questions appropriately

8. Timing is crucial. Ask your questions appropriately when they can contribute most effectively to the discussion. For instance, raising a question about a particular design choice is more relevant during the planning phase than in the final stages of implementation.

You position yourself as an insightful and effective team member by focusing on the intent, relevance, and timing. This method of questioning not only enriches the team's discourse but also solidifies your role as a critical thinker and collaborative contributor, enhancing the overall productivity and success of the team.

Individual contributor

As an engineer and individual contributor, you don't have to be in a leadership position to use the power of a question-based approach. By strategically asking questions, you can contribute to your team's success and demonstrate your value. Here's how you can effectively use this method:

1. Knowing when to ask questions

2. Timing is key. Ask your questions during brainstorming sessions, meetings, or when discussing new projects. Ask questions when you sense a gap in the team's understanding or when you feel a different perspective could add value. For instance, during a project planning session, asking, "Have we considered the scalability of this solution?" can start valuable discussions.

3. Framing questions effectively

4. The way you phrase your questions can either open up a conversation or shut it down. Use open-ended questions to encourage exploration and discussion. For example, instead of asking, "Is this the only solution?" try, "What other solutions might we explore?" This invites diverse opinions and fosters a more inclusive environment.

5. Encouraging collaborative problem-solving

6. Use questions to stimulate collaborative problem-solving. When faced with a challenge, ask the team, "How can we tackle this issue together?" or "What strategies can we employ to overcome this hurdle?" This not only shows your initiative but also your commitment to teamwork.

7. Demonstrating curiosity and willingness to learn

8. Asking questions is a great way to demonstrate your curiosity and eagerness to learn. Inquire about the rationale behind decisions or the specifics of certain methodologies. For example, "Can someone explain the reasoning behind this approach?" shows that you're actively engaged and eager to understand.

9. Facilitating knowledge sharing

10. Use questions to facilitate knowledge sharing within the team. Asking a colleague to elaborate on their expertise helps you learn and allows them to share their insights, creating a learning environment for the entire team.

Using these strategies as an individual contributor enables you to leverage questions to enhance collaboration, aid in problem-solving, and showcase your engagement and value within the team. Adopting this questioning approach marks you as a proactive and insightful team player, laying a solid foundation for future leadership opportunities.

My Experience

My introduction to the question-based leadership approach was under a manager who sincerely believed in the power of this style. He consistently used thought-provoking questions instead of direct instructions, a method that both challenged and propelled our team forward. He recounted a particularly telling experience from his past role as an engineering manager. Despite offering well-reasoned suggestions, his team rarely acted on his advice. Although sound, the ideas were not from the team's discussions or conclusions. This lack of organic ownership led to a reluctance to embrace his suggestions. This experience showed him an essential truth about team dynamics: people are most committed to ideas they have a hand in creating.

This insight was a turning point in my leadership style. In my roles as a tech lead and later as an engineering manager, I embraced this questioning approach. By framing tasks and challenges as questions for the team to address, I saw a rise in ownership and engagement. The team members were not just carrying out tasks but were actively involved in ideation and problem-solving. This heightened involvement led to more innovative solutions and improved work quality.

This approach did more than improve the output quality; it fostered a culture of respect and collaboration. Team members felt more valued and involved, creating a more cohesive and productive work environment. For me, this experience was transformative. I learned the essence of facilitative leadership - empowering and guiding rather than dictating. This journey involved developing a self-motivated, creative, and fully invested team. It has been one of my most significant learning experiences, reinforcing that effective leadership is about nurturing a team's ability to find its path through guided discovery.

Conclusion

Adopting a question-based approach in your role, whether as a leader or a team member, is a transformative strategy that significantly elevates the dynamics and output of your team. This approach goes beyond mere problem-solving; it cultivates a culture of ownership, encourages independent thinking, and fosters a collaborative work environment. By guiding your team through insightful questions rather than directives, you empower them to take the initiative and invest personally in the project's success. This leads to innovative solutions, heightened engagement, and a more motivated team. This method effectively allows individual contributors to demonstrate their value, enhance their problem-solving skills, and position themselves for future leadership roles.

As you navigate your professional journey in software engineering, remember the power of strategic questioning. Encourage yourself and your team to embrace curiosity, seek diverse perspectives, and approach challenges collaboratively. This mindset is key to unlocking the full potential of your team and achieving outstanding results. Take this knowledge forward, apply these principles in your daily interactions, and watch as you and your team grow in capability and success. Your journey toward effective leadership and impactful team contribution starts with a simple yet powerful tool: the right question at the right time.